• About
  • Contact
  • Give
Newsletter
NOQ Report - Conservative Christian News, Opinions, and Quotes
Tuesday, May 24, 2022
  • Home
    • About
    • Give
  • News
  • Opinions
  • Quotes
  • Around the Web
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
    • About
    • Give
  • News
  • Opinions
  • Quotes
  • Around the Web
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
No Result
View All Result
NOQ Report - Conservative Christian News, Opinions, and Quotes
No Result
View All Result

The Atlantic Claims ‘More People Carrying Guns Tends to Result in More Shootings.’ Decades of Data Show They’re Wrong

The Atlantic recently suggested the surge of violence in 2020 was the result of the increase in firearms sales in 2020. The claim is pure fiction.

by Jon Miltimore
December 22, 2021
in Opinions
The Atlantic Claims ‘More People Carrying Guns Tends to Result in More Shootings.’ Decades of Data Show They’re Wrong
TOP MyPillow

A couple of months ago, The Atlantic published an article written by staff writer David A. Graham that explores the surge of violence the United States experienced in 2020.

Overall the article, which analyzes findings from the FBI’s “Uniform Crime Report,” is quite good. It effectively breaks down what we know and—more importantly—what we don’t know about the latest crime trends in America, which in 2020 saw a record surge in the murder rate amid a broader rise of violence.

On one particular point, however, Graham is simply wrong.

Fact Check: ‘More People Carrying Guns Tends to Result in More Shootings’

Graham notes that sales of firearms jumped in 2020, as did police confiscation of illegal guns, and he attempts to tie this to the surge in violence.

MyPatriotSupply 6

“You can ask law-abiding people or you can ask people who do not abide by the law, ‘Why are you armed with a firearm?’ ‘I need to protect myself,’” Richard Rosenfeld, a criminologist at the University of Missouri at St. Louis, tells Graham.

Precisely what Rosenfeld meant by this statement is unclear, but Graham’s next sentence is clear.

“That creates a vicious cycle: More people carrying guns tends to result in more shootings, which in turn heightens the desire to carry a weapon for protection,” Graham writes. “When crime is decreasing, this dynamic helps it continue to fall, but once it begins to rise, the feedback loop turns ugly.”

Whether this claim is Graham’s or Rosenfield’s is unclear. No link or citation is offered to support the assertion. What we do know is the claim that “more people carrying guns tends to result in more shootings” is simply untrue.

As economist Mark Perry pointed out several years ago, the US saw gun violence steadily decrease over multiple decades as gun ownership surged.

“According to data retrieved from the Centers for Disease Control, there were 7 firearm-related homicides for every 100,000 Americans in 1993 (see light blue line in chart),” Perry wrote. “By 2013…the gun homicide rate had fallen by nearly 50% to only 3.6 homicides per 100,000 population. ”

Who wants to tell them?

"More people carrying guns tends to result in more shootings, which in turn heightens the desire to carry a weapon for protection.”
– David Graham writing in @TheAtlantic. pic.twitter.com/lel2gzC41O

— Jon Miltimore (@miltimore79) December 22, 2021

This decline, Perry points out, occurred as the number of privately owned firearms in America surged from about 185 million in 1993 to 357 million in 2013.

And in case you’re wondering, non-fatal shootings followed a similar decline as fatal shootings, as Vox reported at the time. This is part of a larger decline in gun violence that saw “a 39 percent decline in gun homicides between 1993 and 2011 and a staggering 69 percent decline in non-fatal firearms crimes.”

Why Did Violence Fall?

Mr. Graham, who has also reported for Newsweek and The Wall Street Journal, is no doubt a fine writer and reporter. (Many of his points in the article on the FBI’s recent crime report are insightful.) But he’s simply wrong that more people possessing guns “tends to result in more shootings.” The data simply do not support this claim. During this “staggering” decades-long trend of falling firearms crimes, gun ownership steadily increased the entire time.

None of this is to say that gun ownership caused the decline in gun violence. It very well may have, but that’s a more difficult question to answer. For instance, Max Ehrenfreund, a Harvard scientist, has posited that the decline in gun violence may have stemmed from a decline in alcoholism, more police working the streets, the bullish economy of the Reagan years, and even less lead exposure.

Ehrenfreund says researchers don’t really know for certain why the decline in violence happened, but he said one thing is clear: “America has become a much less violent place.”

The decline in gun violence was no doubt linked to many factors, but it’s certainly possible the rise of gun ownership was one of them.

As Lawrence Reed has pointed out, compelling research shows guns prevent some 2.5 million crimes a year in America—6,849 every day—nearly a half million of which are of a life-threatening nature. And it’s not exactly hard to see why. After all, 60 percent of convicted felons told researchers that they avoided committing such crimes when they suspected the target was armed.

If you’re suspicious of these statistics, it’s worth noting that the Centers for Disease Control, in a report commissioned by President Obama following the 2012 Sandy Hook Massacre, estimated that crimes prevented by guns may be even higher: up to 3 million annually (8,200 per day).

Again, we don’t know for certain. These are estimates. What we do know is that guns aren’t just used to commit crimes; they are also used to stop and deter crimes.

Seen and Unseen

In his famous essay That Which is Seen, and That Which is Not Seen, the great economist Frédéric Bastiat noted there is a pervasive tendency for people to focus on the visible effects of a given policy or action and miss the unseen consequences.

GoldCo

Gun control proponents often make this mistake. They focus on crimes committed with guns (the seen)—some of which are truly the things of nightmares—but ignore all the unseen, all of the crimes prevented by firearms.

Some may not be prepared to accept the idea that guns prevent thousands of crimes in America every single day. That’s ok.

But The Atlantic should correct its claim that “more people carrying guns tends to result in more shootings.” It’s pure fiction.

Jon Miltimore

Jon Miltimore

Jonathan Miltimore is the Managing Editor of FEE.org. His writing/reporting has been the subject of articles in TIME magazine, The Wall Street Journal, CNN, Forbes, Fox News, and the Star Tribune.

Bylines: Newsweek, The Washington Times, MSN.com, The Washington Examiner, The Daily Caller, The Federalist, the Epoch Times.

This article was originally published on FEE.org. Read the original article.

Image by Sammy-Sander from Pixabay.

TOP Organic Freeze-Dried Chicken



They’re Trying to Shut Us Down

Over the last several months, I’ve lost count of how many times the powers-that-be have tried to shut us down. They’ve sent hackers at us, forcing us to take extreme measures on web security. They sent attorneys after us, but thankfully we’re not easily intimidated by baseless accusations or threats. They’ve even gone so far as to make physical threats. Those can actually be a bit worrisome but Remington has me covered.

For us to continue to deliver the truth that Americans need to read and hear, we ask you, our amazing audience, for financial assistance. We just launched a GiveSendGo page to help us pay the bills. It’s brand new so don’t be discouraged by the lack of donations there. It’s a funny reality that the fewer the donations that have been made, the less likely people are willing to donate to it. One would think this is counterintuitive, but sometimes people are skeptical because they think that perhaps there’s a reason others haven’t been donating. In our situation, we’re just getting started so please don’t be shy if you have the means to help.

Thank you and God bless!

JD Rucker

GoldCo
Tags: FEEGunsThe AtlanticTop Story
  • Kamala esPuta says:
    December 24, 2021 at 10:44 am

    Who, these days are dumb enough to believe the media?

  • Bypass Big Tech Censors



    My Show

    The Midnight Sentinel

    Our Sponsors

    MyPillow Promo Code NOQ

    MyPatriotSupply
    Z-Stack Life
    Our Gold Guy

    Shows

    7 Globalist Monkeypox Scenarios

    Food = Control

    Pandemic Treaty Is Not a Nothingburger

    The Pandemic Treaty's REAL Threat

    Kathy Barnette Can Win in November

    Bypass Big Tech Censors


    RSS The Federalist

    • David Harsanyi Rejoins The Federalist As Senior Editor
    • Biden Promises To ‘Transition’ America Back To The 1870s
    • Biden Celebrates Record-High Gas Prices As ‘Incredible Transition’
    • ‘Better Call Saul’ Loses Its Light In Shocking Mid-Season Finale
    • If Biden Won’t Counter China, There’s No Point Committing To The Defense Of Taiwan

    RSS The Blaze

    • Trans child molester Hannah Tubbs faces potential life sentence for allegedly beating fellow 'survivalist transient group' member to death with a rock
    • CNN anchor abruptly fact-checks top Biden adviser for claiming Putin is responsible for record-high gas prices
    • Husband, wife hear footsteps in their home in middle of night, so husband grabs gun, then gets in shootout with armed burglar. Husband's aim is better.
    • Horowitz: Biden’s border, criminal justice, health care, and COVID policies responsible for drug poisoning epidemic
    • Mom says 'misgendering' led to SEXUAL HARRASSMENT accusations against 13-year-old son

    RSS PJ Media

    • You Won't Believe Why San Francisco's Radical Mayor Won't March in the City's Pride Parade
    • Durham Trial: The Guy Who Ran FBI Counterintelligence in Trump Russia Scam Has a Really, Really Bad Memory
    • Insanity Wrap: White House Frenzy Over Karine Jean-Pierre's White Straight Male Backup
    • Bite the Big Apple; Don't Mind The Maggots! NYC Is a War Zone, but 'Rapper' Who Shot Cop Goes Free
    • Amber Heard's Litigious PR Guru Gets Hammered by #MeToo Allegations, Threatens to Sue PJ Media

    RSS National File

    • Asian-Owned Jewelry Store Employees Fend Off Smash & Grab Robbers in California
    • EXCLUSIVE: U.S. Air Force Base Hosts Drag Queen Story Time
    • Kandiss Taylor Responds to Brian Kemp’s Chinese Foreign Exhange Student Spy Deal, Perdue’s Pfizer Dealings
    • NSBA Wanted National Guard to Monitor School Board Meetings
    • Virginia School Board Considers Restoring the Names of Confederate Generals to Schools

    RSS Townhall

    • Baby Formula Shortage Shows Biden Wants a Country Without a Future
    • Biden's Barbarity: Violence Is the New Normal
    • Joe Biden's Buffalo Speech Was the Speech of an Indecent Man
    • The Conservative Populist Coalition Has Grown in Pennsylvania. What That Means Going Forward Is Important
    • Modern Journalism: Prostitutes Or Partisan Hacks?

    RSS RedState

    • Report: FBI Uncovers ISIS Plot to Assassinate George W. Bush
    • A Clip of the New Ricky Gervais Netflix Special Is Out and There's No Way It Doesn't Create a Firestorm
    • Democrats Are Scrambling to Find an Alternative to Joe Biden in 2024
    • Pelosi Thumbs Her Nose at Archbishop Who Banned Her From Communion -- Pope Weighs in (Sort Of)
    • Jake Tapper Tests Positive for Coronavirus, Infuriates Staffers by Taping His Show Anyway
    • About
    • Contact
    • Give

    © 2021 NOQ Report

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
      • About
      • Give
    • News
    • Opinions
    • Quotes
    • Around the Web
    • Videos
    • Podcasts

    © 2021 NOQ Report

    Session expired

    Please log in again. The login page will open in a new tab. After logging in you can close it and return to this page.

    >