• About
  • Contact
  • Give
Newsletter
NOQ Report - Conservative Christian News, Opinions, and Quotes
Tuesday, May 24, 2022
  • Home
    • About
    • Give
  • News
  • Opinions
  • Quotes
  • Around the Web
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
    • About
    • Give
  • News
  • Opinions
  • Quotes
  • Around the Web
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
No Result
View All Result
NOQ Report - Conservative Christian News, Opinions, and Quotes
No Result
View All Result

Government-Induced Inequality

by Robert E. Wright
May 9, 2022
in Opinions
Inequality
TOP MyPillow

French economist Thomas Piketty – author of Capital, the least read book of 2014, and now A Brief History of Equality – continues to push a statist agenda in his single-minded quest to reduce global wealth inequality. To reach equal Nirvana, he recently opined, property rights have to be weakened. Apparently, his plan is to impoverish us all by destroying “capitalism.” Problem is, though, governments will get even stronger under his plan and they constitute a major source of inequality.

Say what now? Aren’t our beloved governments veritable modern day Robin Hoods that take from the rich to give to the poor? Not really, it turns out. Aside from increasing economic freedom and a few other Pareto policies, almost everything that governments do make some people better off and others worse off.

Some effects appear to be random, but overall the net beneficiaries tend to be the better educated, better connected sorts who can influence lots of voters and make big campaign contributions. I’m reminded of the joke (suitably adjusted for inflation) that if you default on a $10,000 bank loan, you have a problem, but if you default on a $10 million loan, the bank has a problem. In that vein, if a politician reneges on a campaign promise to help the downtrodden, poor voters have a problem, but if a politician reneges on a promise to a rich guy, the politician has a problem.

Modern governments take from everyone, in many complex ways, ranging from progressive income taxes to regressive payroll and sales taxes to currency taxes (inflation) on savers and the poor. According to a new study by FREEOP, lower income Americans face higher effective rates of inflation than higher income ones. Higher rents and fuel prices hit them harder and they have less ability to temporize by buying in bulk or switching to lower priced alternatives because they already mostly buy the cheapest goods. So even the creeping inflation of the Great Moderation hurt them severely when compounding is considered. Between 2004 and 2020, FREEOP calculated, America’s poorest faced effective inflation rates 71 percentage points higher than those faced by the highest earners.

MyPatriotSupply 6

Governments also take from some by bestowing gifts, from cushy contracts to lucrative liquor licenses, on others. Allowing immigrants to flood into the country, for example, helps the undocumented workers and their employers, and probably helps the overall economy. It also negatively impacts the wages of low-skilled citizens. Similarly, federal housing projects destroyed the homes, businesses, families, and neighborhoods of the poor and replaced them with large towers constructed in the brutalist architectural style. Who benefits again?

And lest we forget, Covid restrictions decimated small businesses while aiding large, corporate ones, and without slowing the pandemic more than an iota. Moreover, it is difficult to reject the hypothesis that the odd contours of the global response to the pandemic were not significantly influenced by the interests of the who’s who in the WHO (World Health Organization) and Big Pharma.

Moreover, I hate to break it to President Biden, but forgiving student loan debt will take money (or purchasing power if paid for by inflation instead of taxes) from most Americans, some rich but many poor. The Green New Deal may also make incomes in the country less equal by eliminating scads of relatively highly paid blue collar jobs.

Government benefits are also messy and, according to progressive thinkers, difficult to discern. If only the “submerged state” emerged from its swampy deaths, the progressives intone, Americans would see how great the government is and how essential it is to their well-being.

But the state submerged itself for a reason: to hide its ineffectiveness. Scholars have exposed FDR’s New Deal as a raw deal, and LBJ’s Great Society as a great big boondoggle. In a commencement speech at Swarthmore College in 1964, President Johnson claimed that “far from crushing the individual, government at its best liberates him from the enslaving forces of his environment.” If that is true, the Great Society was not “government at its best” because it effectively reversed the economic strides African-Americans had been making on their own since the end of World War II.

It isn’t even the case that the government is the best among bad options. Voluntarism can alleviate most problems, including human want, much more effectively than any government bureaucracy can. Most Americans are happy to share resources with the less fortunate. Always have been and hopefully always will be. They do not, however, take kindly to their hard-earned money being wasted by feckless bureaucrats. They would give even more generously than they already do if they could control disbursement more, instead of having the money ripped from each paycheck to support big government programs brimming with waste.

And nowhere does government waste wax more than in poor relief. In addition to the expense of government employees, buildings, automobiles, conferences, and so on, programs designed to aid the poor end up hurting them. Turns out that few poor people ever fall off the infamous benefit “cliffs” where government subsidies abruptly end. But that is only because of the large disincentive “deserts” that induce them to remain poor and dependent on the complex labyrinth of government programs formerly known as the dole well before they reach any benefit cliffs.

Winston-Salem State University economist Craig Richardson and coauthor Zachary Blizard recently documented the size and aridity of the desert facing the poor in their neck of the North Carolina woods. Their findings are truly astonishing. Due to effective marginal tax rates approaching 100 percent, minimum wage workers in Forsyth County are better off not working more hours or obtaining small pay raises until their compensation exceeds $20 an hour. The government is essentially paying them to remain poor. There is no American dream for America’s poor disincentive desert dwellers, unless they can miraculously leap from minimal wages to over $20 per hour.

In fact, a good case can be made that governments constitute the biggest barriers to Americans’ socioeconomic mobility. Government schools, especially those in poorer areas, perform so poorly that many students drop out, or squeak by with weak literacy and numeracy skills. Then they try to make a living cutting hair or watching kids only to be stymied by unnecessary occupational licensing requirements. If they get caught breaking one of government’s gazillion stupid little laws, their lives can quickly spiral into despair and a never-ending succession of minimum wage jobs and taxpayer subsidies.

But even if Piketty and people of his ilk can manage to tax the bejesus out of the rich, those poor folks will remain forever trapped at the low end of the income distribution unless benefit deserts and cliffs are also eliminated. Elimination of work disincentives is the most alluring promise of the basic income guarantee (BIG) or universal basic income schemes (UBI) that have been floated with increasing regularity over the last decade or so. But implementation of a BIG/UBI will not eliminate the inequalities caused by public schools, unnecessary occupational licensing restrictions, or aggressive police enforcement of victimless crimes.

Instead of potentially shocking an already stressed out economy with a big reform like UBI, why not reform all these other governmental causes of inequality first? After allowing the reforms to change attitudes and behaviors, we can reassess to see if UBI is still needed. I suspect it will not be. As most UBI proponents argue, most people want to work, but only if it makes economic sense for them to do so. If they get a good (private) education, are free to run their own businesses, and do not have to worry about falling into the clutches of the criminal justice system “over some bullshit,” most will not just survive, they will thrive, and everyone will be better off for it.

As usual, history could guide us, if only we would allow it. Before the rise of the nanny state, free markets naturally drew resources, including human resources, to their most highly valued use. True, some people worked only for room and board, but if they didn’t like that (and make no mistake, some did), the only thing preventing them from earning more was their own slothfulness in thought or deed. Today, states like California with big, intrusive governments essentially force people to live in tents on the street or in fetid slumtels. California’s income inequality is extreme because its government is extremely intrusive, forcing arrangements that many potential workers or employers eschew.

Before the New Deal, limited government and maximal economic liberty spelled opportunity for all, as even people excluded from the mainstream economy due to their gender, race, religion, or nation of origin could, and did, create their own institutions and employment opportunities, even in finance. Families, friends, and charities helped those who faltered to get “back on their feet.” Massive government programs to aid the poor were unneeded until the government itself turned a recession into a depression, and politicians turned the crisis into an opportunity to garner votes and power, including the power to keep millions dependent on its inequality-inducing statist nostrums.

Image by Darwin Laganzon from Pixabay. Article cross-posted from AIER.

TOP Buy Physical Precious Metals



We Often Feel Like David Taking on Giants

Today’s Goliath is the Mainstream Media Industrial Complex that brainwashes the masses.

Our mission is very straightforward: To counter the false narratives and nefarious agendas destroying America today. It isn’t easy for obvious reasons; despite incredible growth over the last year we are still a very tiny fish in a huge media pond. But we’re fighting and we will continue to do so, Lord willing, for as long as we possibly can. The battle for America’s present and future is too important for us to back down to the giants that stand in our way.

We need help. I don’t want to say “desperately,” but the need is definitely great. If you have the means, please donate through our GivingFuel page, PayPal, or our brand new GiveSendGo page. Your generosity is what keeps these sites running and allows us to get the truth to the masses. We’ve had great success in growing but we know we can do more with your assistance.

Thank you, and God Bless!

JD Rucker


Tags: AIERCapitalismEqualityInequalityLedeSocialismTop Story

Bypass Big Tech Censors



My Show

The Midnight Sentinel

Our Sponsors

MyPillow Promo Code NOQ

MyPatriotSupply
Z-Stack Life
Our Gold Guy

Shows

7 Globalist Monkeypox Scenarios

Food = Control

Pandemic Treaty Is Not a Nothingburger

The Pandemic Treaty's REAL Threat

Kathy Barnette Can Win in November

Bypass Big Tech Censors


RSS The Federalist

  • ‘Better Call Saul’ Loses Its Light In Shocking Mid-Season Finale
  • If Biden Won’t Counter China, There’s No Point Committing To The Defense Of Taiwan
  • Bill Maher Is Not Your New Conservative BFF
  • Thomas Friedman Went To Lunch With Joe Biden And Left Full Of Crap
  • Report: Deadly Summer Blackouts Inevitable As Renewables Struggle To Replace Reliable Energy

RSS The Blaze

  • Man learns the hard way that he should check for snakes before sitting on the toilet
  • Deace: American sovereignty is about to be overruled by the World Health Organization. For your own good, of course.
  • NYC removes the city's last public pay phone, marking the end of an era
  • Poll: Small business owners are increasingly pessimistic about the future of the economy
  • Police, firefighters, and San Francisco mayor won't march in Pride Parade due to a ban against wearing police uniforms

RSS PJ Media

  • Blacks in Georgia Are Surging to the Polls Despite Being 'Suppressed' by 'Jim Crow' Voter Law
  • Time Magazine Tries to Link Buffalo Mass Shooting to Effort to Overturn Roe, and It’s the Dumbest Thing
  • Two Years After George Floyd’s Death, WaPo Can’t Even Remember How He Died
  • The Morning Briefing: Democrats' Georgia Lies Are Being Laid Bare
  • Joe Biden's Buffalo Speech Was the Speech of an Indecent Man

RSS National File

  • EXCLUSIVE: U.S. Air Force Base Hosts Drag Queen Story Time
  • Kandiss Taylor Responds to Brian Kemp’s Chinese Foreign Exhange Student Spy Deal, Perdue’s Pfizer Dealings
  • NSBA Wanted National Guard to Monitor School Board Meetings
  • Virginia School Board Considers Restoring the Names of Confederate Generals to Schools
  • WEF: Armed Swiss Police Detain Journalist Jack Posobiec in Davos

RSS Townhall

  • Baby Formula Shortage Shows Biden Wants a Country Without a Future
  • Biden's Barbarity: Violence Is the New Normal
  • Joe Biden's Buffalo Speech Was the Speech of an Indecent Man
  • The Conservative Populist Coalition Has Grown in Pennsylvania. What That Means Going Forward Is Important
  • Modern Journalism: Prostitutes Or Partisan Hacks?

RSS RedState

  • Democrats Are Scrambling to Find an Alternative to Joe Biden in 2024
  • Pelosi Thumbs Her Nose at Archbishop Who Banned Her From Communion -- Pope Weighs in (Sort Of)
  • Jake Tapper Tests Positive for Coronavirus, Infuriates Staffers by Taping His Show Anyway
  • The Location Tracking Used in '2000 Mules' Is Being Employed to Circumvent the Abortion Industry Much to the Left's Dismay
  • Calvin Klein Salutes Mothers, Including a Pregnant Man Who Isn't a Woman
  • About
  • Contact
  • Give

© 2021 NOQ Report

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
    • About
    • Give
  • News
  • Opinions
  • Quotes
  • Around the Web
  • Videos
  • Podcasts

© 2021 NOQ Report

Session expired

Please log in again. The login page will open in a new tab. After logging in you can close it and return to this page.

>