The Founding Fathers explicitly rejected democracy as a viable form of government. Instead, they opted for republican federalism. Why? Are their reasons still valid, or does federalism need an update?
Article by Caroline Adana originally published at Liberty Nation.
Unlike most modern academics and politicians, the Founding Fathers were highly educated in the history of ancient Greece and Rome. They knew that Athens’ democracy led to disaster and that Sparta’s hierarchical militarism was too rigid and ossified to adapt to change. Rome learned from the Greeks and created the republic, which had elements of Athenian democracy and Spartan hierarchy.
The Founding Fathers adopted an updated version of the republic and added federalism as an extra layer of the division of power to protect against centralized authoritarianism. The purpose is to bring government as close as possible to the governed.
In a raw democracy, the most populous regions would determine the rest of the country’s policy. It would render large parts of the nation chronically unrepresented and subject to the whim of others.
The increased representation of sparsely populated areas in federalism is counterbalanced by reduced centralized power. Although a population minority can overrule the majority, it can mostly do so by veto. Massive change requires a super-majority.
When the Constitution was drafted in 1787, there were fewer than four million people in the United States – about as many as currently reside in the city of Los Angeles. Could the Founders have envisioned the phenomenal growth of the last couple centuries, or would a nation of more than 300 million simply be beyond their imagining? It seems quite likely they simply didn’t know they needed to worry about the scalability of the system.
The result is that the increased population has effectively created precisely the kind of democracy that the Founding Fathers warned about within each state. Take the state of Washington, for instance. President Joe Biden won only 15% of its counties in the 2020 election, but he secured the state with 52.4% of the popular vote. In effect, a few cities determined the outcome of the election.
The pattern repeats across America. Most rural counties are red, but a few urban centers flip the entire state blue. Those who favor democracy think this is the way it should be, but it is not what the Founding Fathers wanted for the country. Federalism was explicitly included to avoid power concentrations.
The conclusion from this analysis is that federalism is partially broken by population growth. Fortunately, there is a way to fix it. Each state could be organized locally as a federation with a state electoral college, which would, in turn, decide the state’s electoral vote at the national level.
This recursive form of federalism ensures that the power is most widely distributed and remains as close to the voters as possible.
The rules for segmenting the electoral votes should be predetermined by law and automatically triggered when certain conditions are satisfied. The two natural criteria are population size and the size of an area. Partitioning could be triggered when the population exceeds some threshold, say, two million people in 1,000 square miles, for example.
Such a rule would slightly favor low-density areas and ensure that urban centers would not chronically overrun the rural regions. Although this would be in the spirit of the Constitution, it is unlikely that such a system would get enough votes to be implemented in the current political environment.
COVID-19 lockdowns are taking down an independent news outlet
Nobody said running a media site would be easy. We could use some help keeping this site afloat.
Colleagues have called me the worst fundraiser ever. My skills are squarely rooted on the journalistic side of running a news outlet. Paying the bills has never been my forte, but we’ve survived. We have ads on the site that help, but since the site’s inception this has been a labor of love that otherwise doesn’t bring in the level of revenue necessary to justify it.
When I left a nice, corporate career in 2017, I did so knowing I wouldn’t make nearly as much money. But what we do at NOQ Report to deliver the truth and fight the progressive mainstream media narrative that has plagued this nation is too important for me to sacrifice it for the sake of wealth. We know we’ll never make a ton of money this way, and we’re okay with that.
Things have become harder with the coronavirus lockdowns. Both ad money and donations that have kept us afloat for a while have dropped dramatically. We thought we could weather the storm, but the resurgence of lockdowns that mainstream media and Democrats are pushing has put our prospects in jeopardy. In short, we are now in desperate need of financial assistance.
The best way NOQ Report readers can help is to donate. Our Giving Fuel page makes it easy to donate one-time or monthly. Alternatively, you can donate through PayPal as well. We need approximately $17,300 to stay afloat through March when we hope the economy will be more open, but more would be wonderful and any amount that brings us closer to our goal is greatly appreciated.
The second way to help is to become a partner. We’ve strongly considered seeking angel investors in the past but because we were paying the bills, it didn’t seem necessary. Now, we’re struggling to pay the bills. This shouldn’t be the case as our traffic the last year has been going up dramatically. June, 2018, we had 11,678 visitors. A year later in June, 2019, we were up to 116,194. In June, 2020, we had 614,192. In November, 2020, we hit 1.2 million visitors.
We’re heading in the right direction and we believe we’re ready talk to patriotic investors who want to not only “get in on the action” but more importantly who want to help America hear the truth. Interested investors should contact me directly with the contact button above.
Promo for Mike Lindell's New Daily Show
As the world spirals towards radical progressivism, the need for truthful journalism has never been greater. But in these times, we need as many conservative media voices as possible. Please help keep NOQ Report going.
Join fellow patriots as we form a grassroots movement to advance the cause of conservatism. The coronavirus crisis has prompted many, even some conservatives, to promote authoritarianism. It’s understandable to some extent now, but it must not be allowed to embed itself in American life. We currently have 11,000+ patriots with us in a very short time. If you are interested, please join us to receive updates.
Promo for Mike Lindell's New Daily Show
All ORIGINAL content on this site is © 2021 NOQ Report. All REPUBLISHED content has received direct or implied permission for reproduction.
With that said, our content may be reproduced and distributed as long as it has a link to the original source and the author is credited prominently. We don’t mind you using our content as long as you help out by giving us credit with a prominent link. If you feel like giving us a tip for the content, we will not object!
JD Rucker – EIC